|
Judge Sheehan
has earned the respect of the legal
profession.
Several years ago, over 400 attorneys
regularly practicing in the Kenton District
Court were asked to anonymously respond to a
survey evaluating Judge Sheehan's performance.
While not a scientific
survey, the results demonstrate the high regard in which Judge Sheehan is
held by area attorneys. We encourage you to
evaluate all candidates for Kenton Circuit Court
using these same criteria.
Please note: this survey should not be confused with similar surveys regularly conducted by the
Northern Kentucky Bar Association.
|
Judge Sheehan... |
Strongly
Agree/
Agree |
| Displays a
sense of basic fairness and justice. |
99% |
| Finds facts and interprets
the law without regard to possible public
criticism |
96% |
| Treats all parties equally
regardless of race, sex, age, ethnicity, social
status or economic status |
96% |
| Strives to avoid conflicts
of interest |
98% |
| Displays adequate knowledge
of substantive law |
99% |
| Displays adequate knowledge
of the rules of evidence and procedure |
98% |
| Written decisions are
clear and thorough |
96% |
| Oral
decisions are clear and thorough |
96% |
| Adequately
explains the nature of the proceedings to
the parties |
99% |
| Adequately informs the
parties of their constitutional and statutory
rights |
100% |
| Gives clear instructions to
the jury |
100% |
| Adequately
researches decisions |
98% |
| Maintains
appropriate courtroom demeanor |
98% |
| Is
courteous and patient |
96% |
| Displays human
understanding and compassion |
98% |
| Works
diligently |
99% |
| Is prompt
in making rulings and rendering decisions |
96% |
| Is
punctual in commencing proceedings |
98% |
| Completes
his dockets within a reasonable time |
96% |
| Considers
all relevant factors in sentencing |
96% |
| Sentences
fairly |
98% |
| Sentences
are consistent |
96% |
Additional survey comments from attorneys who
regularly practice in front of Judge Sheehan:
“I have been impressed with Judge Sheehan’s
performance on the bench.
It is refreshing to
see a judge who cares about the litigants and
who expresses an interest in his job. Also I
have been impressed with Judge Sheehan’s
innovative ideas to resolve matters,
particularly domestic violence matters,
expeditiously and fairly for both parties.”
“Judge Sheehan is one of the few judges
I see
in the law library researching case law.”
“He (Judge Sheehan) has been one of the most
efficient,
professional and accessible judges
I’ve ever known.”
“Judge Sheehan does an excellent job of
balancing fairness and efficiency. Certainly
some of the other judges could take a few
lessons.”
“Judge Sheehan is a polished and professional
judge. It is always a pleasure to be in front of
Judge Sheehan because he is a fair and
compassionate individual.”
“Judge Sheehan’s strength that puts him ahead
of the others is his
continuing respect and
fairness to the plight of the “commoners”; and
the respect shown for all officers of the court
including the attorneys.”
“I think Judge Sheehan displays the proper
temperament in dispensing
justice fairly. He
always ensures that Defendants’ punishment fit
their crimes
and he takes all factors into
consideration which I think is the
true mark of
a great compassionate judge.”
“I think Judge Sheehan is thorough and that
his decisions are fair. Moreover,
he has good
judicial temperament and is clearly in charge of
his courtroom.”
“Judge Sheehan consistently displays
professionalism and an unmatched compassion…”
|
